Showing posts with label Tobin's Q. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tobin's Q. Show all posts

Friday, July 18, 2014

How US R&D Stacks Up With Other Data

Analysts should not have to guess about a business's R&D spending.  It's always in the financial statements for publicly held companies.  Finding the numbers requires some effort because FASB's SFAS 2 requires R&D to be expensed as it is incurred, meaning R&D costs are usually considered to be operating costs rather than capex.  Assembling a comparable number for the entire US is a different project because the data is scattered in several locations.  Government data offers a starting point for the R&D component of spending.

The National Science Foundation has a couple of interesting data sets.  Check out NSF's National Patterns of R&D Resources for a rundown of public R&D spending by source and sector.  The National Science Board's Science and Engineering Indicators report includes a chapter comparing the US R&D commitment to international competitors.  The NCSES InfoBrief for December 2013 has further breakdowns on multiyear R&D spending.  The general conclusions of these three data sources all comport with each other.  Their bottom line is that the US is losing its global lead in R&D spending.  It is worth noting that business R&D spending far outpaces both federal and university spending.

I am intrigued by the US's R&D data because this spending helps determine the nation's future innovation capacity and thus its prosperity.  I would like to explore whether a relationship exists between strong R&D spending and a normal US economy.  I will have to define my terms carefully before I proceed.  I do not yet have a firm definition of what constitutes either variable.  "Strong" R&D spending may be what drives normal GDP growth, and a "normal" economy may be one in which Tobin's Q has a value of 1.0 at its equilibrium.  The St. Louis Fed's FRED historial chart of Tobin's Q shows a big spike in the 1990s when IT spending for Internet connectivity took off.  I would be very intrigued to discover whether a similar spike in national R&D spending contributed to that spike.  It may of course be merely a reflection of the insane NASDAQ valuations for tech companies in that era.  Perhaps a normal economy displays a "Warren Buffett Indicator" close to its historical average.

Be patient as I work through this research idea.  I have other demands on my time.  

Monday, January 17, 2011

Longshoremen Win While Carriers Lose

Union labor has dealt another blow to common sense and good business.  The International Longshoremen's Association has extorted ocean container carriers into shutting out competitive bids for chassis maintenance.  In layman's terms, this means that those container chassis you see hitched to trucks on the highways will cost a lot more to maintain.

Those chassis enable TEU containers to travel directly from ports to logistics distribution centers, saving time and money for importers who rely on streams of bulk deliveries.  Upkeep on those chassis extends their useful lives and increases their salvage value.  Since these chassis are standardized to the point that they are commodified, it makes sense for owners of the commodity pool (i.e., shippers like Maersk who contribute assets to Direct ChassisLink) to find the lowest bidder for maintenance contracts.  Now shippers must restrict themselves to union shops for chassis maintenance thanks to the ILA's totally irresponsible threat of work slowdowns by way of excessively thorough container inspections. 

I am dismayed that shippers who aren't even signatories to the ILA's regional agreement are going along with this nonsense.  They should have applied some game theory and tested the probability of a slowdown and its resolution through arbitration.  I would have called the ILA's bluff and then taken them to court.  Citing the "national security" implications of forced work stoppages at critical infrastructure nodes can be a persuasive argument in this day and age. 

Now shippers have to live with high chassis maintenance costs.  Fleet managers calculating these higher costs will conclude that it's more economical to sell a chassis before its useful life can be extended with high-cost maintenance.  That means higher replacement costs (Tobin's Q alert!) for established shippers and bargain prices for truckers and shippers in emerging markets who want to buy used but functional chassis.  I'll bet shippers servicing Shanghai's exploding TEU traffic would love to get their hands on like-new chassis that don't require union labor. 

Consider what this Journal of Commerce podcast transcript reveals about chassis costs.  Smaller truckers are going to be priced out of the container market if they can't afford to lease chassis from pools, and this will only get worse as maintenance costs rise.  Even larger LTL truckers will be hurt if the daily fee they have to pay to lease from that chassis pool rises thanks to union-driven costs.  I hope YRC Worldwide explains that to their Teamsters the next time they need their concurrence for financial restructuring.  Drivers need to know that longshoremen are not watching their backs with this move. 

The ILA has just handed another competitive advantage to non-U.S. logistics providers.  Way to go, unions.  You've accelerated the outsourcing of your jobs.

Full disclosure:  No position in Maersk or YRCW.

Wednesday, December 10, 2008

Tobin's Q for the S&P 500: More Questions than Answers

Tobin's Q is a financial measure of the replacement costs of a firm's assets. At first glance, both the Investopedia definition and the Wikipedia definition state that a low Q indicates an undervalued stock, so a value investor might take that as a buy signal. Well, we here at Alfidi Capital don't stop at some breezy pop-culture investment waystation. I didn't get my MBA for nothing, so let's consider what academicians have to say about using Tobin's Q:

This measure of performance is not used as often as either rates of return or price-cost margins. If a firm is worth more than its value based on what it would cost to rebuild it, then excess profits are being earned. These profits are above and beyond the level that is necessary to keep the firm in the industry.

The advantage of using Tobin's q is that the difficult problem of estimating either rates of return or marginal costs is avoided. On the other hand, for q to be meaningful, one needs accurate measures of both the market value and replacement cost of a firm's assets.


See that line I bolded? A firm earning excess profits may very well have a durable competitive advantage, which Buffett-style value investors like. A high Tobin's Q would therefore be a very good buy indicator for a stock. So what to do? Here's a thought: Use Tobin's Q in conjunction with other traditional value style metrics, like earnings growth and low debt. A high Q may very well be a good sign of a stock Uncle Warren likes. You'll see me try to apply this approach in future research on the Alfidi Capital main site.

An interesting news item prompted me to bring up this topic:

A global stock slump may have further to go, according to Tobin’s Q ratio, which compares the market value of companies to the cost of their constituent parts, CLSA Ltd. strategist Russell Napier said.

Long story short, the article contends that Tobin's Q for the S+P 500 will drop further in the tradition of past recessions, which saw the ratio plunge below its historical average. The article also quotes other money managers and strategists who have varying opinions on Tobin's Q, mostly because they also look to other indicators to confirm their analysis. Nothing wrong with healthy debate.

I'll confine my use of Tobin's Q to discussions of individual stocks and avoid the macro perspective. I don't have access to the high-powered data sources most economists use for such things (because I'm too cheap to pay), and even if I had the data I'd be mindful of the limitations of aggregating economy-wide estimates of intangibles like intellectual capital. Calculating a single stock's Tobin's Q can be as easy as looking at a balance sheet if you truly understand a company's history and operating environment.